Our Products

Growlin' Gator

 This is a sweeter, milder sauce that has it all- spices, garlic, onions and peppers, as well as a little bite.

Mango Chipotle

A medium heat sauce with a touch of sweetness. 

Ball Kicker

Orange habaneros, garlic, and friends are having a beach party and your taste buds are invited.

Blackbeard's Revenge

The flagship sauce of Castaway! Punishing heat meets complex layers of fruit, peppers, and spice.

Piña Coco

Piña Coco brings the tropical heat! A sauce with fresh pineapple and coconut cream with the burn of scotch bonnet.

The Bottle Bundle

1 bottle of each of our unique sauces for one low price!

Discover, and save on, all four of our sauces in our Bottle Bundle! Click here to check it out! 
Sauces can be purchased locally at Ward’s Supermarket, Ace Hardware University Ave, and Northwest Seafood-Tioga. Looking for samples? Check out our sample pack here. 

Castaway GEAR!

Ball Caps


Pet Bandanas